Automated inequality

Published
0
The writer is deputy resident representative, UNDP Pakistan.
The writer is deputy resident representative, UNDP Pakistan.

ARTIFICIAL intelligence is no longer a distant promise whispered in tech conferences. It is here, in our phones, our banks, our classrooms, in the decisions that quietly shape our lives. It is often described as the new electricity. But electricity lights homes equally. AI does not.

Across the world, governments are moving from experimenting with AI to embedding it in the architecture of governance. Pakistan is no exception, and rightly so. At Indus AI Week 2026, policymakers, entrepreneurs and technologists gathered with a sense of optimism. The National Artificial Intelligence Policy 2025 sets out an ambitious roadmap for skills development, rese­arch ecosystems and responsible adoption.

The future is arriving fast. But the future does not arrive evenly.

Consider Shazia. She lives in a small village. She shares a mobile phone with her husband. She checks her messages when he is home. She has never appeared in a dataset as an independent digital citizen. Yet automated systems in taxation, social protection, employment screening and public services are increasingly being designed to ‘serve’ citizens like her.

The future is arriving fast. But the future does not arrive evenly.

I often think about women like Shazia when we speak about AI readiness and digital transformation. Because AI does not op­­e­­­rate in isolation. It learns from the society it reflects. And when society is unequal, alg­orithms absorb that inequality quietly, and at scale.

The numbers tell a sobering story. According to UNDP’s National Human Development Report 2023, only 26 per cent of women in Pakistan use the internet, compared to 47pc of men. In rural areas, just 7pc of women are online; 83pc say male family members influence or control their access to mobile phones.

These are not just statistics. They determine who becomes visible to digital systems and who does not. AI models are trained on digital footprints: mobility patterns, transaction histories, search behaviour, service usage. When women’s economic participation and daily realities are underrepresented in data, algorithms treat those absences as normal. Bias does not need malicious intent to become structural. It only needs to be encoded into the system.

Pakistan’s AI policy speaks the language of inclusion. It commits to expanding AI training for women and underserved communities. It promotes ethical principles. These commitments matter. But attending training is not the same as shaping governance.

Responsible AI cannot remain aspirational. Without binding safeguards such as bias audits, gender impact assessments, structured representation of women, gender expertise in oversight bodies, inclusion risks becoming rhetorical. As eligibility scoring and administrative decisions move into automated systems, institutional pow­er shifts into code. If gender perspectives are absent at the design stage, exclusion beco­mes systematic rather than accidental.

This is not a technical glitch. It is a governance choice.

And the consequences are both economic and social. Globally, generative AI skills command wage premiums of up to 36pc, according to the World Economic Forum. Yet women hold only around 22pc of AI-related roles, according to Unesco. If Pakistan’s AI transition expands high-paying digital sectors without correcting participation gaps, inequality will widen rather than narrow.

We have seen this story before. MIT research found that commercial facial recognition systems were significantly less accurate for darker-skinned women than for lighter-skinned men, not because programmers intended discrimination, but because training data reflected exis­ting bias. Tech­nolo­­gy scales what it is fed.

Pakistan already faces governance and data coordination challenges re­­flected in global AI readiness assessm­ents. If gender is not embedded into these frameworks from the outset, it will become an afterthought, and afterthoughts in code are costly.

But there is still a window. Before procurement rules solidify; before datasets are locked into automated workflows; before institutional design becomes path dependent. Embedding gender considerations into AI readiness assessments is not about optics. It is about structural safeguards: examining dataset composition, oversight mechanisms, audit capacity, and disaggregated data standards before systems scale nationally.

Shazia may never attend an AI Week. She may never write a line of code. But autom­ated systems designed today will shape the services she receives, the benefits she qualifies for, and the risks she is scored against. Pakistan will surely adopt AI. The question is whether it will automate inequality or de­­sign governance strong enough to prevent it. Because once inequality is written into code, it becomes far harder to erase.

The writer is deputy resident representative, UNDP Pakistan.

Published in Dawn, March 8th, 2026

Opinion

Editorial

Kashmir unresolved
Updated 30 Sep, 2026

Kashmir unresolved

The just solution lies in India addressing the issue through a trilateral dialogue involving the legitimate representatives of the Kashmiri people and Pakistan.
Water shortage
30 Sep, 2026

Water shortage

THAT the country is entering the Rabi season with an anticipated water shortage of nearly 25pc, the lowest carryover...
Young hearts
30 Sep, 2026

Young hearts

THE observance may have passed, but the message of World Heart Day should not fade with it. The occasion is a useful...
Terror and politics
Updated 29 Sep, 2026

Terror and politics

There is an urgent need to tone down the rhetoric and tackle terrorism as a collective challenge for both the affected provinces and the federation.
Watching the glaciers
29 Sep, 2026

Watching the glaciers

THE latest signs from Pakistan’s mountains are worrying. Suparco says the number of unfrozen glacial lakes it...
Dangerous agenda
29 Sep, 2026

Dangerous agenda

AS the world remains fixated on the US-Iran conflict, elsewhere in the Middle East, Israel is consolidating its grip...